Agenda and minutes

Place and Resources Scrutiny Committee - Tuesday, 16th November, 2021 10.00 am

Venue: Virtual Meeting via MS Teams Live Event

Contact: Lindsey Watson  01305 252209 / Email:


No. Item


Declarations of interest

To disclose any pecuniary, other registrable or non-registrable interests as set out in the adopted Code of Conduct. In making their disclosure councillors are asked to state the agenda item, the nature of the interest and any action they propose to take as part of their declaration.


If required, further advice should be sought from the Monitoring Officer in advance of the meeting.


There were no declarations of interest.


Chairman's Update

To receive any updates from the Chairman of the Place and Resources Scrutiny Committee.


Following recent changes to committee memberships, the Chairman thanked Councillors Adkins and Parkes for their contributions as former members of the committee and welcomed Councillors Brown and Turner to the committee.


The Chairman provided statements in relation to the Land Charges Service and Information Compliance items as set out at appendix 1.


The Chairman provided the following statement:


‘In the light of the situation with Covid-19 case rates, Dorset Council's Chief Executive - Matt Prosser has exercised his delegated powers to continue to hold virtual informal committee meetings.


Where a decision is required, committee members will express a ‘minded to’ decision in respect of recommendations set out in officer reports, with decisions being taken under officer delegated authority in the light of ‘minded to’ decisions expressed by members in the virtual meetings.  Any decisions or recommendations required will be confirmed by the appropriate officer at the conclusion of the committee’s debate on an agenda item.’


Public Participation

To receive questions or statements on the business of the committee from town and parish councils and members of the public.


Public speaking has been suspended for virtual committee meetings during the Covid-19 crisis and public participation will be dealt with through written submissions only.


Members of the public who live, work or represent an organisation within the Dorset Council area, may submit up to two questions or a statement of up to a maximum of 450 words.  All submissions must be sent electronically to by the deadline set out below.  When submitting a question please indicate who the question is for and include your name, address and contact details.  Questions and statements received in line with the council’s rules for public participation will be published as a supplement to the agenda.


Questions will be read out by an officer of the council and a response given by the appropriate Portfolio Holder or officer at the meeting.  All questions, statements and responses will be published in full within the minutes of the meeting.  The deadline for submission of the full text of a question or statement is 8.30am on Wednesday 10 November 2021.


There were no questions or statements from members of the public or local organisations.


Questions from Members

To receive questions submitted by councillors. The deadline for receipt of questions is 8.30am on Wednesday 10 November 2021.


There were no questions from councillors.


Dorset Council External Communications pdf icon PDF 302 KB

To consider a report of the Service Manager – Communications and Engagement.

Additional documents:


The committee received a report of the Service Manager – Communications and Engagement, which provided an overview of aspects of Dorset Council’s external communications work.  This included the protocol for notifying ward councillors of communications relevant to their ward, an overview of how the council used social media and work to reach younger people.


Councillors considered the issues arising from the report and during discussion the following points were raised:


·            The importance of notifying and consulting with ward councillors where possible, before media releases were put out in their area

·            A comment was made with regard to the reference in the council’s Media Protocol to councillors acting as spokespeople for Dorset Council and that some councillors may have differing views on what the council was doing.  The Service Manager agreed that the wording would be looked at

·            Consideration of training for councillors in dealing with the media

·            Detail provided of the work undertaken with town and parish councils in partnership with the Dorset Association of Parish and Town Councils

·            The importance of the role of town and parish councils in this area should be strengthened in the council’s documents.  This would be reviewed

·            Communications provided with regard to highways issues and an understanding that sometimes these had to be sent out quickly.  The Portfolio Holder for Highways, Travel and Environment noted that information was included on the Travel Dorset part of the council’s website.  He would also speak to the Service Manager as to whether notifications in this area could be improved, in particular for planned works

·            Information provided on the 5-stage process for issuing media releases

·            Information on work undertaken to engage with younger people.  The Service Manager noted she was happy to look into further ways to promote this area

·            The council continued to look for ways to improve engagement with residents

·            Detail provided of how activity across the Communications and Engagement Team was monitored.


Social Mobility in Dorset pdf icon PDF 459 KB

To consider a report of the Research Officer.


The committee received a report which set out the council’s approach to tackling inequalities and the improvement of social mobility.  A wide-ranging discussion was held in response to the issues set out in the report and which would inform further work to be undertaken in this area.  Points were raised in the following areas:


·            Discussion around issues of deprivation in Weymouth and Portland including education, employment and housing.  Recognition that there was a need to improve education and employment opportunities and raise aspirations

·            A conversation was taking place with MPs to try and tackle these issues and also how the Government measured prosperity – Dorset was seen as a prosperous area but it was recognised that there were areas of significant deprivation in Weymouth and Portland and lobbying continued for the Government to recognise this

·            Examples were provided of work being undertaken by the council and in conjunction with partners to address the issues covered in the report

·            Issues raised around academies would be raised with Children’s Services

·            There was a need to support and grow existing employment opportunities and also bring new employers into the area

·            Employment issues in Weymouth and Portland were discussed and the need for further investment in employment infrastructure and facilitation of job creation

·            An overview of the Stronger Neighbourhoods Strategy was provided, which had an initial focus on Weymouth and Portland.  Councillors were encouraged to contribute to this

·            It would take some time to develop measures of success and this would involve communities and stakeholders

·            A point was noted that particular areas for focus for the council were education and training and job creation and the links between these, particularly in Weymouth and Portland

·            Issues around the real living wage were raised and this would be raised with the S151 Officer following the meeting

·            The council would review lessons learnt in the wider social mobility area from experience in Weymouth and Portland and also from other councils

·            Housing was included as a theme in the Stronger Neighbourhoods Strategy and examples of programmes underway were provided

·            Documents needed to be clear and accessible to the public.


Former St Mary's School in Shaftesbury Acquisition pdf icon PDF 434 KB

To consider a report of the Corporate Director for Education and Learning.


The committee received and considered a report of the Corporate Director for Education and Learning, which provided an overview of the acquisition of the former St Mary’s School site near Shaftesbury, to become the Dorset Centre of Excellence incorporating a special educational needs and disability (SEND) school.


Councillors discussed the issues set out in the report and the following points were raised:


·            There was regular monitoring of progress with the project and confidence that it would come in on budget

·            There was a clear timeline for delivery to get the school into operation

·            A request made for progress reporting on major projects and how this could be linked to the council’s performance reporting framework

·            The creation of a centre of excellence would bring together colleagues to work on research and good practice and could also include support to other local authorities

·            The People and Health Scrutiny Committee would be receiving a report during 2022 with regard to the operation of the school on the site

·            Education provision on the site was key but work was to be undertaken on provision of services to transition from Children’s to Adults services

·            Any other use of the site would need to be complimentary to education provision.


Dorset Council Climate and Ecological Emergency Strategy Progress Report pdf icon PDF 450 KB

To consider a report of the Sustainability Team Manager.

Additional documents:


The committee received a report to provide a review of progress made in delivering the Dorset Council Climate and Ecological Emergency Strategy and Action Plan.  This was the first of a bi-annual progress report to be provided to the committee.


Councillors considered the issues arising from the report and during discussion the following points were noted:


·            Work to establish a scoring mechanism for Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) to evaluate progress

·            Funding opportunities for green tourism

·            The availability of electric charging points across Dorset and private sector and Government investment to continue the roll out

·            Councillors were encouraged to read a document produced by the Local Enterprise Partnership which set out future requirements for energy and the need to enhance capacity

·            Work was being undertaken with partners to develop plans for solar farms throughout the council area

·            Some indicators were already included in the council’s performance system and further work was required to set out a methodology for future extended reporting.


In accordance with the Constitution, at this point in the meeting it was proposed by M Roberts seconded by D Tooke that the meeting continue beyond 3 hours.  This was supported by the committee.


Discussion continued with points raised as follows:


·            Issues around sustainable energy production were raised

·            Officer resourcing for this area was discussed and it was noted that a new corporate director post had been established.  In addition, it was noted that resources were drawn in from officers working in a wide range of services across the council for particular areas or projects

·            The transport vision for Dorset was highlighted including discussions around the council’s own transport fleet

·            Examples of the council working in partnership with other organisations and business were provided

·            Reference was made to flood management issues.

5-minute adjournment

The Chairman announced that there would be a 5-minute adjournment at this point in the meeting and that the committee would recommence at 1.45pm.


Performance Scrutiny

A review of the relevant Dorset Council performance dashboard to inform the scrutiny committee’s forward plan and identify items for deep dives.


Committee members to flag up if any areas for potential review:

Operational – Corporate:
Councillors Brian Heatley and David Shortell

Operational – Place: Councillors Mark Roberts, David Tooke and Jon Andrews

HR: Councillors Andy Canning and Bill Trite


The Chairman, Councillor Shane Bartlett, maintains an overview of all the above areas.



The Service Manager for Business Intelligence and Performance provided an overview of the Performance Dashboard that had been set up for the monitoring of performance for areas covered by the remit of the committee.  This included an overview of the key features of the dashboard and the information that was available.  A link to the performance dashboard is provided below for information:


Place and Resources Scrutiny Committee Performance Dashboard


The following points were noted:


·            Consideration to be given to how monitoring of progress with major projects could be enhanced in the performance monitoring system

·            Follow up reports on Information Compliance and the Local Land Charges Service would be provided at the meeting on 25 January 2022

·            The committee to undertake further investigation in relation to the level of sickness absence in Children’s Services

·            Further commentary was to be provided in respect of data breaches within the council and was also to be discussed with the Audit and Governance Committee

·            The addition of wider trend graphs to cover information related to the previous financial year

·            PL22 major applications overturned at appeal – no data had been provided in the performance dashboard and this would be checked following the meeting.


Place and Resources Scrutiny Committee Forward Plan pdf icon PDF 223 KB

To review the Place and Resources Scrutiny Committee Forward Plan.


Councillors reviewed the committee’s forward plan.  The next meeting of the committee would be held on 10 December 2021 and would be to consider the council’s budget proposals for 2022/23.  In addition, councillors noted items to be considered at the meeting of the committee on 25 January 2022.


The Chairman reminded councillors that they could submit an item for potential review by the committee.



Cabinet Forward Plan and Decisions pdf icon PDF 459 KB

To review the Cabinet Forward Plan and decisions taken at recent meetings.


The Cabinet Forward Plan and decisions of recent meetings are provided to members of the Place & Resources Scrutiny Committee to review and identify any potential post decision scrutiny to be undertaken, by scheduling items into the forward plan to review after a period of implementation.

Additional documents:


The committee noted the Cabinet Forward Plan and decisions taken at recent meetings, which the committee could use in order to identify potential areas for post decision review.


The Chairman asked that the committee undertaken a post-decision review of the item ‘Phase 2 Parking Charges Project’, at an appropriate meeting six months after implementation of the decision.


Urgent items

To consider any items of business which the Chairman has had prior notification and considers to be urgent pursuant to section 100B (4) b) of the Local Government Act 1972. The reason for the urgency shall be recorded in the minutes.


There were no urgent items.


Exempt Business

To move the exclusion of the press and the public for the following item in view of the likely disclosure of exempt information within the meaning of paragraph x of schedule 12 A to the Local Government Act 1972 (as amended).


The public and the press will be asked to leave the meeting whilst the item of business is considered.


There is no exempt business.


There was no exempt business.

Appendix 1 - Chairman's Update

Agenda item 3 – Chairman’s Update


Land Charges Service Update for the Chair of Place and Resources Scrutiny Committee – from Grace Evans – Head of Legal Services


We received a report about the Land Charges Service, at our September meeting.  The report explained the work of the service, the delayed response times, the reason for those delays, action being taken to address them and details of future transformation work.  Our Committee asked for a progress report for today’s Committee with a further report to a future Committee about the scope of a project converge the land charges registers.


Due to the timing of our Committee meeting, which would have required a report to be written before October performance data is reported, I have received the following progress update and a formal report on progress will be presented to our January 2022 meeting:


·       The number of search requests during September and October have continued at an increased level compared with comparative months in 2019. There has not been a significant reduction following the end of the stamp duty holiday at the end of September.


·       The 6 new members of staff who joined our team in mid-September have received core training and have been working on searches and gaining experience since mid-October.


·       East area land charges services migrated into the new whole Dorset system during early October.  All land charges areas are now within the new system.


·       We have a new single team email address for enquiries to replace the five existing email addresses and this is available on our website page.


·       The current average response time, for the whole Dorset area at the end of October, is 61 working days from the date of receipt.  We continue to publish response times on our website, updated fortnightly and also provide this information on an automated email response to search enquiries.


·       We have a larger team, new ICT system, and targets in place to reduce waiting times.  The first reduction is planned for the end of November.



Update on Information Compliance items – from Marc Eyre, Service Manager for Assurance


The information compliance key performance indicators for Freedom of Information and Subject Access Requests were discussed at the September committee meeting.  It was noted that there were improvements in the Freedom of Information response rates but that Subject Access Request response compliance remained low.  As reported, discussions were underway with Children’s Services to identify how improvements could be made.  These discussions are ongoing and there is positive progress, but timings have been delayed due to the recent demands on resources for the Ofsted inspection.  An update will therefore be provided at the January meeting.  The Committee will be pleased to know that Freedom of Information compliance continues to show improvement.  In the meantime, the team are looking at how the KPI can be improved to provide a clearer measurement of significant non-compliance, as requested by members.